The viio7 as Subdominant

Daniel Arthurs & Diego Cubero, University of North Texas

The viio7 chord is generally understood as having dominant function. Oxford Music Online, for example, defines the viio7 chord as functioning "like a dominant chord." While in most cases the viio7 does indeed act as a dominant, this paper examines several contexts in which the viio7 functions as subdominant.

The idea that a viio7 chord can have a subdominant function is not new. The earliest recognition of the subdominant features contained within viio7 is first encountered in Rameau's 1737 treatise, Génération harmonique, where Rameau explains the viio7 chord as a combination of dominant and subdominant harmonies: scale-degrees 7 and 2 from V, 4 and 6 from IV.

This paper explores examples of several characteristic voice-leading schemas where the viio7 functions clearly as a subdominant. Subdominant viio7s are found in the music of J. S. Bach, Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven, Chopin, Schubert, Ferdinand David, Mendelssohn, Schumann, and Brahms, among others. Important to this paper is the general sense that these examples are not exceptions to the norm, but, indeed, seem suggestive of a more common type of viio7 that partakes in plagal motions, and thereby communicates subdominant function.

The expressive implications are important here, for plagal motions historically have been characterized as backwards looking (after Michael Klein), as presenting a kind of "unrequited" character (after Heather Platt), or as "other" (after Margaret Notley). To ascribe Dominant function to these viio7 chords is to miss their expressive value.